By Mikhail A. Molchanov

In this provocative learn, Mikhail A. Molchanov analyzes the political and cultural elements that underlie glossy nationwide identities in Russia and Ukraine and systematically compares the political cultures of those traditionally related, but profoundly varied international locations. He perspectives nationwide identities as built, a number of, and occasionally competing photographs of the nationwide self. He sees political tradition as a key determinant of nationwide identification and emphasizes the serious position it performs as a motor vehicle of switch and improvement. Like tradition, nationwide id is a built phenomenon, a method to prepare and constitution cultural assets to slot present political and social needs.

the writer argues that family and foreign elements form nationwide identities, which aren't an inherent attribute of a humans, yet come up in interplay with the nationwide "other." The "self-other" courting is accordingly a key component of nationwide identification, quite in newly self sustaining states, of which Ukraine is a chief instance. In culturally related duos, like Russia and Ukrain, historic and cultural proximity complicate discussion, but let jointly appropriate accommodations.

Following the breakup of the Soviet Union, nationwide identities needed to be reconstructed or re-created. the connection among Russians, the middle political humans within the U.S.S.R., and Ukrainians, the perennial junior brothers, replaced following the disintegration of the Soviet country. Molchanov questions the level to which Russians were in a position to build an identification except that of the Soviet Union, arguing that the procedure denationalized them in an try and create the appropriate A Soviet guy. He sees Ukraine as either depending on Russia and suffering to forge a brand new nationwide id in wide awake competition to Russian impact. Molchanov doubts the viability of a Ukrainian nationalist venture, simply because he believes majority of the Ukrainian inhabitants gravitate towards Russia culturally and linguistically.

Molchanov sees Ukraine neither as Russia's sufferer, nor as its contrary. in contrast to those that worry a resurgent Russia and who argue that it may be contained by way of neighborhood nationalisms within the "near abroad." Molchanov believes this procedure can lead basically to estrangement among Russia and its acquaintances. additionally, Russia=s fresh commencing and proven aid of the U.S. is just too helpful to the realm to be sacrificed to a brand new version of the containment strategy.


Show description

Read or Download Political Culture and National Identity in Russian-Ukrainian Relations (Eastern European Studies, 17) PDF

Best russian & former soviet union books

Candidate Strategies and Electoral Competition in the Russian Federation: Democracy without Foundation

Within the early Nineteen Nineties, aggressive elections within the Russian Federation signaled the tip to the authoritarian political process ruled via a unmarried political get together. greater than ten years and plenty of elections later, a unmarried occasion led via Russian President Vladimir Putin threatens to finish Russia's democratic scan.

Chechnya’s Terrorist Network: The Evolution of Terrorism in Russia's North Caucasus

This expert's view into the strategic instructions, strategies, leaders, and demanding assaults hooked up to Chechen and North Caucasus terrorists examines the network's operations in addition to the luck of Russia's counterterrorist responses.

This authoritative account lines the emergence of terrorism within the risky quarter of the North Caucasus from its origins within the early Nineteen Nineties throughout the cutting-edge. It provides a close exam of neighborhood and worldwide counterterrorism strategies—everything from army strength, to international relations, to politicization—providing invaluable perception into potent tools for scuffling with terrorism the following and world wide.

This candid paintings uncovers the roots of Russian terrorism and gives a ancient review of the stipulations that complex terrorism and its remarkable conflict practices, together with radioactive assaults and suicide assaults by means of ladies. writer and local Russian speaker, Elena Pokalova, analyzes favourite terrorist teams resembling Islamic overseas Peacekeeping Brigade, Riyad us-Saliheyn Martyrs' Brigade, and unique objective Islamic Regiment, and divulges the neighborhood and international effect of the Caucasus Emirate at the move.

Additional info for Political Culture and National Identity in Russian-Ukrainian Relations (Eastern European Studies, 17)

Sample text

We will consider these explanations in turn, looking at how more general assumptions reflect on the respective view of Ukraine and Ukrainians. The earliest accounts saw all policies originating from Moscow or Saint Petersburg as essentially motivated by base impulses of the Great Russian chauvinism. The writers of this persuasion tended to equate political hegemony with national oppression and disregarded the elaborate politics of alliances that made the very existence of both the Russian Empire and the Soviet Union possible.

Zbigniew Brzezinski, Edward Keenan, Henry Kissinger, Richard Pipes, and Stephen White, among others, saw the early Muscovy, the Russian Empire, the Soviet Union, and now, it seems, postcommunist Russia, too, as equally prone to absolutism, despotism, and servility. In this rendering, Soviet and then post-Soviet political culture appears but a bleak shadow of the mysteriously immortal political culture of the Russian monarchy, as it came into existence circa s. 3 This approach inadvertently seconds the idea that the communists were indeed successful in changing traditional ways of life to the point of their virtual disappearance.

Though denied their national state, Ukrainian aristocracy actively participated in medieval Lithuanian and Polish-Lithuanian states of the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries and Ukrainian clergy—in the building of the Russian Empire since the s. Ukrainians, as no other people, were intimately connected with the structures of power in Moscow czardom, the Russian Empire, and the Soviet Union. Historically, the Ukrainian aristocratic families—Razumovskie, Vyshnevetskie, Skoropadskie, Glinki, and others—were highly visible in the upper echelons of Russian nobility.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.38 of 5 – based on 42 votes